OPEN 7 DAYS - 8.30AM - 5.30PM

THE BAIT DEBATE!

What Works, What Doesn't & What Fish Love.

Pilchards or squid? Fresh or frozen? Big baits or small? Ask a group of Kiwi anglers what works best and you're bound to start a debate! Everyone has their favourite bait, their secret tricks and a story about the one that got away. But when it comes to catching fish, is there really one bait that beats the rest? From trusty pilchards and squid to freshly caught baitfish, we're diving into the bait debate to discover what works, what doesn't and what might give you the edge on your next fishing trip.
 
THE BAIT LINE-UP – MEET THE CONTENDERS!
When it comes to bait fishing in New Zealand, a few familiar favourites have earned their place in the chilly bin. But each has its strengths, and knowing when to use them can make all the difference.
 
PILCHARDS – THE ALL-ROUNDER
A Kiwi fishing favourite! Pilchards are oily, naturally scented and appealing to a wide range of species, particularly Snapper and Kahawai. They're great for straylining, surfcasting and general bait fishing, although their softer flesh means they can be easily stripped by smaller fish.
 
SQUID – THE TOUGH CONTENDER
Squid is a reliable option when you need bait that stays on the hook. Its firm, rubbery texture makes it ideal for fishing in stronger currents or when pesky bait thieves are about. Use it whole, in strips or as smaller pieces for a variety of fish species.
 
BONITO – THE OILY FAVOURITE
Packed with natural oils and a strong scent, bonito is a popular choice for Snapper and other predatory fish. Cut it into strips or chunks depending on your target species. Its softer flesh can attract unwanted attention from smaller fish, so secure it well.
 
MULLET – THE HARD-WORKING OPTION
Mullet is a versatile bait with relatively firm flesh that holds up well on the hook. It's a handy choice for surfcasting, straylining and fishing around reefs, especially when you want something more durable than pilchards.
 
CATCH YOUR OWN – FRESH NZ BAITFISH!
Why buy bait when you can catch your own? Yellowtail (jack mackerel), koheru and kahawai are popular choices for Kiwi anglers looking for fresh, locally caught bait.
Jack mackerel and koheru are particularly prized as live baits for Kingfish, while fresh Kahawai strips can be excellent for Snapper.
 
Catching your own also gives you the flexibility to fish it fresh, use suitable species as live bait or freeze some for another day. Just remember that jack mackerel and koheru fall under specified baitfish limits, while kahawai is subject to general finfish rules.
 
Check the latest Fisheries New Zealand recreational fishing rules before collecting your own bait.
 
SHELLFISH – THE WILD CARDS
Mussels, pipis and tuatua can all be excellent bait alternatives, particularly for species such as Tarakihi and Moki. Their natural scent makes them appealing to a variety of fish, although their softer texture means they may need securing to the hook with bait elastic.
 
Always check local shellfish gathering limits, closures and restrictions before collecting your own, as rules vary by area.
The verdict? There's no single winner! The best bait depends on what you're targeting, where you're fishing and how you present it.
 
FRESH VS FROZEN – DOES IT REALLY MATTER?
It's one of fishing's oldest arguments. Is freshly caught bait really better, or can a bag of frozen pilchards do the job just as well?
 
TEAM FRESH
Fresh bait can offer natural texture and scent, particularly when it's been caught and prepared properly. Freshly caught mackerel, kahawai and other suitable baitfish are popular with experienced anglers.
 
TEAM FROZEN
Don't underestimate frozen bait! Good-quality bait that's been frozen and stored correctly can still be highly effective. It's convenient, readily available and means you can head out fishing without having to catch your bait first.
The trick is looking after it. Keep bait chilled or frozen until needed, avoid leaving it sitting in the sun and only thaw what you're likely to use.
 
AND WHAT ABOUT SALTED BAIT?
Salted bait is another great option when you want something tougher and longer-lasting on the hook. The salting process helps firm up the flesh, making it easier to handle and less likely to fall apart, particularly when surfcasting or fishing in stronger currents.
 
For a convenient, ready-to-use option, try Longlife Salted Mullet 1kg or Longlife Salted Bonito 1kg, both available at Smart Marine.
The verdict? Fresh bait has its advantages, but well-kept frozen bait can absolutely deliver. Quality, storage and presentation often matter more than simply choosing fresh over frozen.
 
WHAT'S ON THE MENU? – MATCH THE BAIT TO THE FISH!
Different fish have different feeding habits, so matching your bait to your target species is a great place to start.
 
Target species Popular bait choices:
Snapper: Pilchards, squid, bonito, mullet, jack mackerel and kahawai strips
Kahawai: Pilchards, small baitfish, mackerel and bonito strips
Gurnard: Mullet strips, bonito and crabs
Tarakihi: Squid, pipis, tuatua and small bonito strips
Kingfish: Live jack mackerel, koheru and kahawai; squid
 
These are tried-and-tested starting points rather than hard-and-fast rules. Fish can be surprisingly fussy one day and willing to eat almost anything the next!
 
Top tip: If the bites aren't coming, try changing your bait before changing your fishing spot. Sometimes a different texture, bait size or presentation is all it takes.
 
BIGGER BAIT, BIGGER FISH?
We've all heard it: Big bait, big fish! But is it really that simple?
Larger baits can be useful when targeting bigger predators, particularly when you want a substantial offering that smaller fish may struggle to swallow. But a bigger bait doesn't automatically mean a bigger catch.
Sometimes smaller, neatly presented baits are far more effective, especially for species with smaller mouths or when fish are feeding cautiously.
 
A FEW BAIT PRESENTATION TRICKS:
• Match the hook to the bait: Make sure the hook point remains exposed and thebait isn't bunched up around it.
• Keep it secure: Use bait cotton to help hold soft pilchards and other delicate baits securely on the hook. Try Glowmate Glow In The Dark Bait Cotton 50m, with the added benefit of glowing in low-light conditions.
• Make it look natural: Avoid oversized, awkward chunks when a neatly cut strip will do the job.
• Change things up: Experiment with bait size and shape when the fishing slows.
 
The verdict? It's not always about going bigger. A well-presented bait of the right size can be much more tempting than a massive chunk dangling awkwardly from a hook.
 
DON'T FORGET THE BERLEY!
You've chosen your bait, rigged it perfectly and found a promising fishing spot. Now it's time to get the fish interested!
Berley works by releasing small particles and scent into the water, creating a trail that can attract fish towards your fishing area.
It's particularly popular for Snapper fishing around reefs, in harbours and from the rocks, where a steady berley trail can help bring fish within reach.
 
THE SECRET TO A GOOD BERLEY TRAIL
Consistency is key. Rather than dumping a huge amount into the water at once, aim for a steady release that encourages fish to investigate and stay in the area.
Position your berley pot or bag to suit the current, so the trail carries towards the area you're fishing.
 
GET THE BERLEY WORKING!
The Penguin 5kg Frozen Berley Bomb is a convenient option for getting a scent trail going. For something a little different, try Fish Magnet Premium NZ Mussel Berley. Made in Marlborough from 100% natural mussels, with no added fish, oils or binders, it's a great option for attracting Snapper and other fish. Available in 1.5kg and 4kg bombs. You can also use Sea Harvester Raw Fish Oil when making your own berley mix.
 
Top tip: Try to fish your bait within the berley trail rather than away from it. The idea is to draw fish towards your hooks, not feed them somewhere else!
 
Remember to use berley responsibly and avoid leaving unwanted bait, packaging or fishing waste behind.
 
SO, WHO WINS THE BAIT DEBATE?
Fresh or frozen? Pilchards or squid? Big bait or small? The truth is, there's no one-size-fits-all answer. Every fishing trip is different, and what works brilliantly one day might not get a nibble the next. The best anglers know when to experiment, adapt and keep trying until they find what the fish are hungry for. Ready to settle the debate for yourself? Explore Smart Marine's Bait & Berley range, stock up on your favourites and put them to the test on your next fishing adventure!
 
Tight lines and happy baiting!
Total Shares: 0

Back to Blog

Subscribe for Special Offers

Sign up successful!